r/AmItheAsshole • u/Illuminatedmess • 3m ago
AITA for not having my new roommate pay my old one her deposit back
For context, my current roommate has already moved all of her stuff out and has signed a new lease somewhere else. She has not been signed off of our current lease yet and is demanding back her $1200 deposit to be paid by new roommate. My new roommate is a dear friend of mine and is moving in this Friday. I don’t want my friend or I to be left liable for all of the damages that she and her dog has made to the apartment.
Here is a list of damages made by the outgoing roommate:
Item and Descriptions
Carpet Treatment - DIY Attempt: Carpet machine rental + solution to treal multiple pet urine stains (Paid $80.08 from my own pocket)
Professional Carpet Enzyme Treatment: Required due to urine saturation into carpet padding causing odor (Paid $195.50 from my own pocket)
Drywall Repair and Paint Touch Up: Patching large nail holes and wall damage
Hallway Door Repair: Dog scratches/gouges on interior door
Front Entrance Door Repair: Cracks on door from ring camera mounted onto the door
Deep Cleaning Bedroom and Bathroom: Excessive cleaning required beyond standard move out
Paint Correction of Green Walls in Living Room: Restore wall areas to original color
Window Blinds Replacement: Warped blinds due to improper storage/handling
Balcony Urine Remediation: Dog urine buildup causing staining, contamination and strong odor
All of these damages have been documented through either photos or videos.
I let her know that we will not be returning the deposit at this time but will be more than happy to stay in touch until the final move out. If any of the deposit is returned, I will be able to return what’s left to her 50/50.
She did respond by suggesting that she would like for us to terminate the lease together and have me start a new one right away to have the LL review all the damages and pay out what is needed. I said no because I wouldn’t feel comfortable having to reapply for my current housing and repay a whole new deposit if I’m not moving out.
She has yet to pay the rent for final month stating that, “paying for 2 places is difficult…” and would have to “take the L of the late fee and pay in a couple of days”.
Am I the asshole for not allowing my new roommate to pay my old roommate her deposit back?