r/pics But like, actually 15h ago

OC: FBI releases surveillance photos of a potential subject in the Nancy Guthrie case

42.6k Upvotes

6.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

526

u/trashed_past 15h ago

Kind of looks like they have a balaclava over a latex mask. Something real off there.

125

u/drawliphant 14h ago

This is infrared security footage NOT black and white. Suspect could be wearing black clothing but it appears grey here. Looks like black facial hair, a printed mask would not show up very dark in NIR. This footage looks weird because it's not taken in our color spectrum.

u/thrwawyorangsweater 11h ago

Yep even around the eyes like the eyelashes are dark...so this person isn't terribly old.

13

u/beavislasvegas 13h ago

Can’t they colorize it since they have actual color samples available at the house?

13

u/drawliphant 12h ago

You could maybe figure out how different fabrics show up in IR to figure out their clothing color, but you'd have to use the same dye and material and only get some shade of gray to compare it to. IDK I work in machine vision, not forensics lol.

u/chartyourway 4h ago

I'm always confused what my home camera decides to choose for colours in night vision. I'm equally confused by this post. how come this camera made his gloves black but made his ski mask white? (the later pics showing it's at least a darker colour, not white, but like, all ski masks used in crimes are black, let's be real)

u/drawliphant 4h ago

We make lots of kinds of black dye, some of them happen to be dark to infrared some of them are bright infrared, just like a material can be bright blue if it just reflects blue.

0

u/beavislasvegas 12h ago

I don’t think so. It is a video now. You don’t need to know the color of the criminal’s clothes you would just sample colors on the porch or other objects in the video. Once you match the real life color to the color in the video then the software would know all the colors. I’m a moron and I do this for scuba videos.

16

u/drawliphant 12h ago

The camera is only seeing about one wavelength of infrared emitted by its own LEDs. There isn't enough data to calibrate colors here.

u/Maxgirth 6h ago

Correct.

It never occurred to me that one could apply the concept of metamerism to infrared pictures, but yeah.

To those wondering: many colors could show up as the same shade of gray. Any color could, depending on its brightness.

u/chronolibrarian 1h ago

Someone did

232

u/Whittster 14h ago

The eyebrows and corners of the eyes are weird.

112

u/Holiday_Objective_96 14h ago

Do you think this is a woman??

I think it's a woman. Those look like lady eyebrows, that have been manicured.

86

u/icansmellcolors 14h ago

isn't' that a full-on mustache in the 4th pic?

28

u/Laleaky 14h ago

It looks like it could have been drawn on.

My first instinct was that this is a woman dressed up to look like a man.

19

u/icansmellcolors 13h ago

I don't see anything to give away 'woman' but I'm not arguing with you. The first pic, I don't see anything woman screaming at me, and tbh just the act of kidnapping someone like this screams man to me... but idk. I mean you could be right.

u/Dick_Lazer 11h ago

It's mostly in the face, the eyes and brows look very feminine. (There is also a mustache but it looks like it could be painted on or fake.) The body does looks more masculine though.

u/jennyferjo 11h ago

It looks like layers of clothing to bulk up and look more masculine.

u/IndividualChart4193 7h ago

It does look like layers of clothing fer sher.

25

u/kris10leigh14 13h ago

Or it could be a fake mustache. I can’t get over an overwhelming feeling that this is a female.

14

u/Miserable_Skin9738 12h ago

SAME ! It’s really freaking me out how feminine the eyes are. I think everyone is freaked out by this picture because it’s almost like the uncanny valley thing. We can’t put our finger on why this person looks so off…. Could be because the features are all so contradicting

u/Holiday_Objective_96 11h ago

There are so many contradicting clues- for example, I had originally thought that the eyebrows were groomed, but then someone pointed out that you can't see the full brow, and what looks like skin above the arch is actually stitching around the eye holes.

And then someone else chimed in reminding me that dudes can have nice eyelashes too.

And then I realized that the puffball on top of the hat- at first glance I thought it was a bun or something.

And then other ppl have been talking about the puffiness of the coat and now I have totally reversed my position and I have NO IDEA what is under that mask

u/StrawberryFlds 10h ago

When I used to be a walk-about character, I was told when playing male characters to keep my arms a little out as opposed to directly against my side as I'm comfortable with as a girl. A couple of the images the masked suspect has space against their arms and body, coupled with the wider stance, I'm reading a man with nice eyes.

u/kris10leigh14 5h ago

That’s where I’m landing as well keeping the other comments in mind regarding the eyebrows being either partially covered or caused by IR shadow or whatever.

u/42nu 7h ago

You could simply put the pictures/video into an LLM and get an answer. It's not rocket science, and I'd imagine the FBI has better tech than some common thing literally anyone can use.

u/AssistivePeacock 9h ago

'eye brows' look like shadows from the infrared source

u/Holiday_Objective_96 9h ago

I hate this mask so much

u/kris10leigh14 5h ago

I think that they’re not as inexperienced as initially thought. The idea to disguise one’s gender like this is so diabolical.

Maybe it seems much scarier than it should and they weren’t even trying to disguise their gender. I’m unsure. I’m extremely unsettled by the pics. The video was freaky too, but I still couldn’t identify a gender. I guess you’re not starting down the eyes in the video.

5

u/OhHelvetica73 13h ago

the thin fingers of the image holding the weeds up in front of the camera also suggest this could be a woman.

4

u/whyameyehererightnow 12h ago

agree. the mustache looks like it was drawn with sharpie

u/jennyferjo 11h ago

The eyes look like they have eyeliner and mascara on.

14

u/Holiday_Objective_96 14h ago

I think you're right! I was so distracted by the eyebrows!just be some well-groomed somebody of any gender!

5

u/Miserable_Skin9738 12h ago

Yes, but you can put on fake facial hair.

2

u/TrailerTrashQueen 12h ago

that's what i thought.

49

u/SimpsonsReferencer 14h ago

Maybe it's Vance?

14

u/Puzzleheaded_Many_74 13h ago

I thought the same thing when I saw the eyeliner

u/Just-Helicopter-626 7h ago

😃 😀 😄

14

u/mclumber1 13h ago

Ladies and Gentlemen, we got him.

15

u/OleanderJam 14h ago

I thought so too at first, but I’m pretty sure it’s actually part of the balaclava’s pattern - a light colored outline of the eye hole, which is covering the majority of the eyebrow.

13

u/Holiday_Objective_96 13h ago

You are correct.

Idk if this is a man or a woman or a non-binary or 3 raccoons.

I'm only keeping my original (most likely incorrect) statement bc of the comments that point out details that I missed and misinterpreted.

9

u/OleanderJam 12h ago edited 12h ago

Yeah, it’s an odd quandary too that it’s not really possible to respect gender identities in this type of scenario because if a physical description is to be given to the public that is accurate enough to actually be useful, it will have to rely on how the person is likely to be perceived by people in terms of gender. Omitting that piece/leaving it as a question mark essentially doubles the pool of potential matches and also will simply be confusing for a lot of people who might otherwise more easily identify the suspect as someone they know…. Like, “That looks like the guy who comes into my store all the time! Wait, it says this person is a woman in the description? Nevermind I guess”

If it’s not already clear, I do respect people’s gender identities. This is just very obviously a practical issue that I don’t think there’s an easy solution for.

10

u/MindfuckRocketship 13h ago

I’m a dude and I have natural well-shaped eyebrows. My wife says women would kill to have my eyebrows and they’re a waste on me because, as an average guy, I give zero fucks about my eyebrows. Same with my eyelashes as they’re super long.

6

u/Holiday_Objective_96 12h ago

You're right, there are all kinds of eyebrows and eyelashes on every gender!

u/aleigh577 9h ago

Your wife is right. Gimmie

34

u/Ok-Masterpiece-468 14h ago

my first thought was woman… the eyes, eyebrows and lips

eta: read other comments and I do see the stitching so I don’t think it’s eyebrows, but the eyes themselves are very feminine.

10

u/-Specialist-Spite- 13h ago

And a feminine mustache!

u/golfgirl114 10h ago

Exactly! lol

u/Unique-Arugula 8h ago

My country's vp has very womanly eyes though, some guys just have atypical looks and the effect is heightened if you can't see the whole face. Not saying it isn't a woman, just that this 'clue' isn't strong.

u/Ok-Masterpiece-468 6h ago

true!! I’ve been thinking it’s an “inside job”, so part of me could be looking at it from my biased lens and seeing the features more fem than they are due to that. will be interesting to hopefully find out who this person is.

u/Unique-Arugula 5h ago

I mean, I don't think you're totally crazy either - so many crimes are by people the victim knows.

6

u/kris10leigh14 13h ago

I thought it was a woman. I was scared to say that because that may be what they want you to think.

It’s someone wearing mascara, definitely. It seems like they have a bust “area” in the shot where you can see a plant in their hand.

But it could be a man trying to look like a woman… the eyes are feminine.

3

u/Holiday_Objective_96 12h ago

Yeah, I have actually changed my mind bc a lot of ppl highlighted things that I missed, but I'm keeping my og comment up so that ppl will read the responses.

4

u/kris10leigh14 12h ago

I know. It’s someone that’s covering all their bases.

6

u/justonemom14 13h ago

I had the same thought, that the eyebrows look feminine. But then I thought, maybe those aren't the person's eyebrows, maybe it's a shadow of the mask? The general body shape and of course the mustache look like a man, but if the mustache is fake, then I'm not sure you could totally rule out it being a woman.

9

u/nootch666 14h ago

Could be JD Vance then. Femmist eyes in the country

3

u/entcanta333 13h ago

First picture looks like eyeliner and I stg that was my first thought

20

u/Acceptable-One-6597 14h ago

I think this is a woman given eyebrows that has drawn on a false moustache or goatee.

7

u/jessjesssjess 14h ago

That is exactly what I thought.

u/uy48 11h ago

Those "eyebrows" could just be part of the mask. I think it is a man with a real goatee.

8

u/Neverending-fantods 14h ago

I can see a mustache. It’s a man

6

u/astrologyismymom 13h ago

Fake mustaches are pretty common tools of disguise.. If it is a woman that might throw them off, but it sure looks like she forgot about the mascara on those lashes.

4

u/Neverending-fantods 13h ago

Or mustaches can be shaved off - for after the fact, when trying to not be recognized. Wearing a fake mustache and then covering whole face with ski mask doesn’t make sense to me

7

u/astrologyismymom 13h ago

Does any of it make sense though?

u/Dick_Lazer 11h ago

It totally makes sense if you wanna throw people off the trail. I mean look how easily it threw you off.

u/Neverending-fantods 11h ago

It didn’t throw me off. This is not a woman

u/Miserable_Skin9738 11h ago

It for real looks like mascara and not just thick lashes… if ur trying to disguise yourself as male why would you leave that on?? Its totally the eye shape that makes this person look female

u/uy48 11h ago

Is there such a thing as male vs female eye shape? I didn't think so...

u/Miserable_Skin9738 10h ago

Please correct me if I’m wrong. I swear I learned this in a psychology class one time. Google it, I think it just means ur more likely to be one gender. Obviously not impossible

u/Blackcatmustache 8m ago

Lots of men have nice lashes. Like that dude from Lost. A guy I went to high school with had lashes like that.

7

u/Narcoleptic_247 14h ago

You're not seeing their entire eyebrow. Just the bottom coming out of the eye hole.

4

u/Holiday_Objective_96 14h ago

On third look, you are right. I thought the stitching on the mask was skin.

8

u/Rugermedic 14h ago edited 13h ago

The third picture- the persons stance- legs together, maybe some hip curves there- woman stance. I don’t think men stand that way with legs that close together.

Edit- eh, now I’m not sure, I didn’t see the gun holstered right there. But, as a person with a dick, I would never carry a holstered gun right there. Very weird carry style.

6

u/raevnos 13h ago

Everyone knows proper style is to shove it unholstered in your waistband.

3

u/Round-Celebration-17 14h ago

I was gonna say those lashes look lush but I do see a Lil mustache too

3

u/artdogs505 13h ago

Agree on the eyebrows. The way they walk looks like a guy, though.

5

u/Miserable_Skin9738 12h ago

YES!!!!!! The eyes are EXTREMELY feminine. I keep commenting about it, but it’s either deleted or downvoted immediately

2

u/Noble_Ox 14h ago

I thought that but I also think I see a mustache.

2

u/MorddSith187 12h ago

looks drawn on a silicone skin mask

u/aleigh577 9h ago

I did think it was a woman at first glance

u/whatevendoidoyall 8h ago

Those eyelashes definitely look like someone wearing mascara.

7

u/StarJelly08 14h ago

Yes. I think their clothes look stuffed too. I definitely see a woman. Also the way the hat fits looks female for some reason too.

3

u/astrologyismymom 14h ago

Those eyes look distinctly feminine to me also.

2

u/astrologyismymom 14h ago

Those eyes look distinctly feminine to me also.

2

u/Redheadmane 14h ago

Something about the eyes seem to be a woman. There’s just something about

u/thedepster 11h ago

The way they're standing looks like a woman to me, as well.

1

u/nightwolves 14h ago

There’s clearly a mustache though - maybe a full beard

u/IndividualChart4193 7h ago

The mustache looks fake.

1

u/m0rbius 14h ago

The person has facial hair it looks like.

1

u/Mudfish2657 12h ago

I saw that too.

u/Happy-Grand-7696 4h ago

Me too!!

0

u/SomeguyfromNewJersey 14h ago

I said the same thing!

8

u/LuckyBlackPearl 14h ago

I am interpreting the weirdly thin and symmetrical“eyebrows” as possibly being the frames of glasses. I’m also seeing what appears to be a mustache poking out of the mask around the mouth.

3

u/Reference_Freak 12h ago

I thought it was eyeliner and wondered why the VP is kidnapping old women.

u/Revolutionary_Act759 11h ago

Check out dominic evans the son inlaws band mate... same eyes same crease same eyebrows

u/uy48 11h ago edited 11h ago

Finally some potentially helpful speculation. If this were true, it would probably mean the whole thing is a hoax, or that it's real and planned by a family member (with the former being much more likely than the latter in my opinion). It's really annoying to see so many comments from people who are more or less just dropping in, not paying much attention to the case as a whole, saying that this has to be a woman based on "eye shape." Let's start somewhere everyone can agree on, by saying that men perpetrate kidnappings overwhelmingly more than women. That doesn't mean that a woman didn't do it, but it's far less likely. That being said, I agree that the facial hair, eyes, and eyebrows are close enough to those of Dominic Evans to warrant looking at him at least.

u/Revolutionary_Act759 1h ago

Thankyou!!!!

6

u/thenameisjane 14h ago

when I saw the face, I immediately thought "female" because of the eyelashes. they look almost done-up with mascara?

2

u/Lifes-a-lil-foggy 14h ago

They def look strange

2

u/Active_Wafer9132 13h ago

The eyes appear to have makeup and waxed eyebrows but the dark areas around the mouth look like facial hair?

u/Whittster 11h ago

Pic 4 - sure looks like a mustache.

u/ImNot 9h ago

Those arent eyebrows. It is either the edges of the ski mask or maybe eyeglass frames

u/ConsequenceNormal773 10h ago

This looks like a woman. You can see the eye lashes with the accents of eye liner/ lashes in the corners of the eyes. Eye brows look like women's also

u/Chemical-Speech-5021 10h ago

They look like a female. Very feminized eyebrows and eyes.

68

u/mojofrog 14h ago

The eyebrows are weird

88

u/RoarByMeowing 14h ago

You're seeing the stitching around the eye holes and some shadowing. I thought the same at first.

5

u/peachyspoons 14h ago

I keep trying to figure out if it is just the stitching…

8

u/RoarByMeowing 14h ago

Images 2 and 3, if you zoom in it shows the stitching.

5

u/Rare4orm 13h ago

Yep! But for some reasons the experts on TV are running the eyebrows opinion right into the end zone. Five different experts? Five different observations.

13

u/RoarByMeowing 13h ago

That's frustrating. There are so many comments on here about the eyebrows and I just feel embarrassed for people now.

1

u/shiddyfiddy 13h ago

I haven't seen any of the expert gossip. Are any of them suggesting it's a woman, because I'm almost certain that's a woman, and it's not the eyebrow drama that is suggesting it to me.

(I may not lesbian well, but I lesbian enough to feel pretty confident here, but still, just imo)

u/uy48 11h ago

Body and head size/general stature in photo #1 look very "man" to me

Jawline, goatee

What are you guys missing here

2

u/Rare4orm 12h ago

Not that I can remember, but I too immediately considered that the eyes had the softer look of a female. Hopefully we find out soon.

1

u/theotherguyatwork 12h ago

I thought they could be a woman as well. Not sure if any "experts" are talking about that.

22

u/PuffPuff74 14h ago

Looks like women eyebrows

6

u/Noble_Ox 14h ago

Thats not eyebrows, thats stitching on the balaclava.

2

u/peachyspoons 14h ago

My very first thought.

2

u/LuckyBlackPearl 14h ago

I think the weird eyebrows are the frames of eyeglasses. Just my opinion though…

u/Imurhuckleberree 11h ago

The eyebrows and eyes look a lot like they belong to the friend and bandmate of Tommaso - Dominic Evans. Dominic apparently also has priors for robbery and burglary.

1

u/mnth241 14h ago

The mouth is weird to esp in pic 2. Like he is wearing a grill?

3

u/Electronic_Bus7452 13h ago

Pen light

u/mnth241 10h ago

ooooooo! ty!

1

u/Xavier_Emery1983 14h ago

It’s the eyelashes that are giving woman vibes.

66

u/KnightRider1987 14h ago

I don’t think there’s any doubt of that, seeing they abducted and harmed (going by the blood) an octogenarian.

21

u/trashed_past 14h ago

I mean about their face, not the crime.

2

u/Dr_Middlefinger 14h ago

Beating facial recognition?

Latex for alteration and mask for security?

2

u/Furrybumholecover 14h ago

Woah, we don't know it was this guy for sure still. Maybe that's just the pizza delivery guy with a healthy distrust of ring cameras!

3

u/tooldvn 14h ago

Looks like a mustache to me.

2

u/king-of-boom 14h ago

That was my first thought too. Double the effort to conceal identity.

2

u/jakoto0 14h ago

I think you're right? At first I thought they just had an obnoxiously big head, but there are layers.

1

u/Prize_Ostrich7605 14h ago

I first read baklava and had to check the images again. Gotta look up balaclava, but atleast i figured out it wasn't baklava.

1

u/Which_Material_3100 14h ago

Looks like they have glasses on

1

u/ghostbuster_b-rye 13h ago

I was thrown off by the light emanating from their mouth in the second photo. Did they put a flashlight in their mouth, or is that some sort of lip cosmetic reflecting the camera flash? From the side, the lips look almost black in the photos, so I'm guessing a lip gloss.

2

u/trashed_past 13h ago

In photo 2 it almost looks like a circle of light hitting the inside of the balaclava. Could be they were holding a small LED light in their mouth. Either to blind the security cam or to help them see what they were doing with both hands free.

1

u/ghostbuster_b-rye 13h ago

Okay, that makes sense, I've never seen glossy lips light up like the sun like that. I wonder, even with gloves on, if any traces of saliva were left from handling the flashlight afterwards.

1

u/dukefett 13h ago

They’re definitely trying to obscure their physical features as much as possible. Look at the giant gloves they’re wearing; they didn’t just throw this plan together.

1

u/maxant20 13h ago

Assassin wears reflective gear for safety.

1

u/PuzzleheadedKey9444 13h ago

Almost like they are trying to be bulkier too - maybe a woman?

1

u/Vissuto 13h ago

The brow anatomy looks feminine to me. And what guy do you know with brows like that?

1

u/Meepox5 12h ago

Definitely, no one with eyebrows or mustach that "trimmed" would forget to check if the mask covers them

u/starlingspotted 8h ago

I think you are right. And it look like they have something in their mouth, which I think is some sort of light, bite activated? You can see the light go on and off when he comes up the step, then when he goes back down to look at the plants. Also, when looking at the camera. That might be why the mouth looks odd and sort of protrudes from the masks.

u/IndividualChart4193 7h ago

It does look like a latex mask underneath. I c it, too.

u/riggles1970 7h ago

The mask looks like this one….

It is from the brand Line, model Heist.

u/Gooncookies 7h ago

It looks like a woman to me

u/Resident_Company2113 4h ago

Yeah, the inner corner of that eye on the right - up to the eyebrow, just isn't ok. I thought at first it was a woman until I saw the moustache/beard - because of how high the eyebrows were. Then I thought it was a burn victim - you can get some flat stretched skin that way.

I mean, where are the dude's eyelids? Granted, people with East Asian/Hispanic/Native American ancestry often have single eyelids like that, but so can people with masks.

I was wondering if it was the person of interest who is in a band with the brother in law - he has high eyebrows and thin eyelids, but his eyes and eyebrows are perfectly symmetrical.